Soft M&M Cookies
Soft M&M Cookies
Soft M&M cookies are delicious, quick and easy to whip up, and the recipe leaves room for variation in the recipe by changing the candies.

What is better than fresh from the oven cookies? Not much! Cookies are delicious, have endless varieties, freeze well, and everyone loves them. They are the perfect food to bring to gatherings, pack in lunches, or even to give as gifts. My kids’ favourite cookies are filled with chocolate, candy, or a mix of the two.  Because of this, soft M&M cookies are definitely one of my families favourite cookies!


Soft M&M cookies are delicious, quick and easy to whip up, and the recipe leaves room for variation in the recipe by changing up the additions like different candies, chocolate chips, or even nuts. For my family, I use half chocolate chips and half M&Ms. These cookies also turn out really well when adjusting the size of the cookie. They can be made as small or big as you want, just be sure to adjust the cooking time accordingly. You want to bake them until the cookies are just turning brown on the edges but not fully cooked in the centre, as they will finish cooking  on the pan after removing them from the oven. This will get you that soft, chewy cookie that my kids just can’t get enough of. Of course if you prefer a crispier cookie, just cook a little longer until your desired doneness.


soft m&m cookies

Soft M&M Cookies Recipe



3 cups flour

2 tsp baking powder

1 tsp baking soda

½ tsp salt

1 cup margarine

1 cup sugar

2/3 cup brown sugar

2 eggs

4 tsp vanilla extract

3 cups M&M’s, chocolate chips, or a mixture of the two




Preheat oven to 350 and line two cookie sheets with parchment paper.


Mix flour, baking powder, baking soda and salt together in a bowl until combined.


With an electric mixer, beat butter, white, and brown sugar together until light and fluffy.


Add eggs and vanilla extract and continue mixing until thoroughly combined.


Stir flour mixture into the butter and sugar mixture until combined.


Add M&M’s, chocolate chips, or a mix of the two and stir to combine.


Drop spoons of dough onto cookie sheet in about 2 tablespoon portions, leaving room for the cookies to spread as they cook.


soft m&m cookies

Bake for 8-12 minutes until edges of cookies are beginning to brown.


Leave cookies to cool on baking pan for approximately 10 minutes, as they will continue to cook on the pan.


Move cookies onto a cooling rack to cool completely before storing in an air tight container. Enjoy!


soft m&m cookies
Recent Posts
  • Companion PlantingWhat is Companion Planting
    In Gardening and Livestock
    As a dedicated homesteader, I've always found immense joy in the symbiotic relationships that thrive in my garden. One of the most fascinating practices I've embraced is companion planting. It's a method that not only makes gardening more efficient but also more rewarding. Today, I want to share my experiences and insights into the magical world of companion planting. […]
  • asparagus5 Delicious Ways to Use Asparagus
    In Cooking
    Incorporating asparagus into your homestead meals is a delicious way to celebrate the bounty of your garden or local market. Whether you prefer it grilled, sauteed, or pickled, there's no shortage of ways to enjoy this versatile vegetable. […]
  • spring foragingSpring Foraging in Northwestern Ontario
    In Country Living
    This blog post celebrates the beauty and bounty of spring foraging in Northwestern Ontario, providing readers with inspiration and practical tips for exploring the wilderness and harvesting its edible treasures. Whether you're a seasoned forager or new to the experience, there's something magical about connecting with nature and discovering its culinary delights firsthand. […]
  • ruffed grouseRuffed Grouse Hunting in Northwestern Ontario
    In Country Living
    For many of us, hunting isn't just a hobby; it's a way of life, a means of providing sustenance directly from the wilderness that surrounds us. In the boreal forests of northwestern Ontario, one of the most exhilarating pursuits is hunting the elusive ruffed grouse. […]
  • white tail deerWhy the .243 is the Perfect Companion for White Tail Hunting in Northwestern Ontario
    In Country Living
    As a homesteader in the wilds of Northwestern Ontario, every hunting season brings both excitement and a deep sense of responsibility. The quest for sustenance and connection to the land drives us to the forests, where the majestic white-tailed deer roam. […]
  • tire swingEnhancing Your Homestead with Upcycling
    In Country Living
    This spring, unleash your creativity and embrace the art of upcycling to enhance your homestead with sustainable and stylish DIY projects. Not only will you breathe new life into old materials, but you'll also cultivate a deeper connection to the land and the resources it provides. […]
  • baby cucumbersA Guide to Starting Seedlings Indoors
    In Gardening and Livestock
    Starting seedlings indoors is a rewarding and essential step in the journey toward a successful garden harvest. By following these simple steps and providing proper care and attention, you can nurture healthy, robust seedlings that will thrive when transplanted into the garden later in the season. […]
  • natural wood log end tableA Sneak Peek at Our Upcoming Reclaimed Wood Furniture Collection
    In Country Living
    The anticipation is palpable as we put the final touches on our Reclaimed Wood Furniture Collection. Join us as we count down the days until its launch and celebrate the beauty of reclaimed wood and the promise of a more sustainable tomorrow. At RainyRiverHomesteaders.com, the best is yet to come. […]
  • garden planA Homesteader’s Guide: Planning Your Canadian Garden
    In Gardening and Livestock
    . By following these tips and techniques, you can create a productive and sustainable garden that provides you with an abundance of fresh, healthy food for you and your family to enjoy. […]
  • garden planning10 Winter Gardening Preparations for a Bountiful Homestead Harvest
    In Gardening and Livestock
    Winter Gardening Prep As winter blankets our homestead […]
As an affiliate marketer, we may earn commissions from the links on our website.